By: Samantha Borcy
What Suzie Saw in Marshall’s Work
One of the most interesting dynamics in the creation of Match: The Situational Coaching® Approach to Meeting Leaders Where They Are is that Marshall Goldsmith had been practicing a form of situational coaching for decades without naming it that way. When Suzie Bishop began studying his work closely, she kept recognizing parallels between how he instinctively coached and the principles of Situational Leadership® she had spent her career working with and applying. He was reading the person and the situation in every conversation. He was giving different amounts of direction and support based on what someone needed in that specific moment. He was adjusting his approach as his clients changed. What Suzie brought to the collaboration was the ability to see the structure underneath what Marshall was doing by instinct and translate it into a framework other coaches could learn and use. Marshall brought the decades of lived experience doing it. Neither of them would have arrived at Match alone. It took his experience and her ability to recognize the pattern in that experience to create something transferable.
Why Experienced Coaches Are the Hardest to Reach
One of the sharpest observations in Match is about what can go wrong with experience. A coach discovers an approach that works. People reinforce them for it. It becomes part of their identity and their brand. Eventually they start protecting the method. The habits that made them effective become the habits that limit them, because they have stopped asking what this person needs and started asking what do I usually do here. Suzie and Marshall are not asking experienced coaches to abandon their wisdom. They are asking them to loosen their attachment to one way of delivering it. The difference matters. Everything a seasoned coach has learned, every insight, every earned judgment, every hard-won understanding of what people need when they are growing, is still valuable. What the book asks them to let go of is the belief that their preferred way of coaching is the right way to coach everyone. The question that cuts through that habit is the one at the heart of the whole framework: what does this person need from me right now?
Ability, Willingness, and What Gets Hidden
The concept of Performance Readiness® in Match is built on two dimensions: ability and willingness. Suzie is specific about how each one tends to get misread. Ability is easier to overestimate. We confuse potential or past success with current demonstrated capability. Someone may absolutely be capable of something, but the relevant question in this model is whether they are demonstrating it consistently right now, in this specific situation. Willingness is trickier, because confidence, commitment, and motivation are internal. People can mask hesitation. They can say they are committed when their behavior suggests otherwise. That is why the book argues that readiness should not become a label a coach assigns privately. It should be a conversation grounded in observable behavior, one where the coach names what they are seeing and checks whether that is an accurate read. The coaching relationship is not improved by a coach who has diagnosed someone correctly but kept that assessment entirely to themselves. The diagnosis becomes useful when it opens a conversation.
When Resistance Meets Coaching
Coaching someone who is genuinely resistant to feedback is one of the most difficult situations any coach faces, and Match addresses it directly. The first instinct is often to try to convince them they are wrong, which almost always increases resistance rather than reducing it. What Suzie and Marshall recommend instead is curiosity about the gap between how the person sees themselves and how the people around them experience them. What are they trying to accomplish? What matters to them? What are the people around them observing? And is their current behavior actually helping them get the outcome they say they want? The coach’s neutrality is powerful in that moment precisely because the coach is not the boss and is not trying to win an argument. But there is a limit the book is honest about. Coaching requires willingness. You cannot work harder on someone’s development than they are willing to work themselves. If a person refuses entirely to examine their contribution or consider the possibility of change, there may not yet be a viable coaching engagement. That is not a failure of the method. It is an honest recognition of what coaching can and cannot do.
What a Successful Coaching Relationship Looks Like When It Ends
The sign of a successful coaching engagement, according to Match, is not that the client needs the coach more. It is that they need the coach differently. They see themselves more clearly. They have developed greater ability and confidence. They can recognize some of their own patterns before someone else has to point them out. They have tools they can keep applying after the formal engagement ends. For the coach, success requires being comfortable with that independence, because the goal was never to make yourself indispensable. The goal was development. And the impact ideally keeps moving outward after the relationship ends. The person who has been coached takes what they learned into how they lead their team, communicate with the people closest to them, make decisions, and influence others. That ripple effect is where both Suzie and Marshall find the most meaning in this work. The framework creates repeatability. The philosophy keeps it anchored in results that actually show up in people’s lives.
Pick up your copy of Match: The Situational Coaching Approach to Meeting Leaders Where They Are by Suzie Bishop and Marshall Goldsmith on Amazon today.




