The Role of Feedback in Surgical Success: Insights by John J. Cascone, MD

The Role of Feedback in Surgical Success: Insights by John J. Cascone, MD

In the high-stakes world of surgery, the margin for error is minimal. Achieving success in this field requires not just skill and knowledge but also an ongoing commitment to learning and improvement. One key factor that often goes overlooked in the pursuit of surgical excellence is the role of feedback. Feedback, both from patients and peers, is crucial for surgeons to refine their techniques, enhance patient care, and ultimately, save more lives. Drawing on the expertise of a seasoned surgeon, John J. Cascone, MD we explore how feedback can pave the way for surgical success.

Understanding the Value of Feedback

Feedback in surgery serves as a mirror, reflecting the outcomes of surgical procedures, patient satisfaction, and areas needing improvement. It’s an essential tool for continuous learning and professional development. Here’s why feedback is invaluable:

  • Improves Surgical Skills: Regular feedback helps surgeons identify specific areas of their practice that need enhancement.
  • Enhances Patient Care: Insights from patient feedback can lead to changes that improve the overall patient experience.
  • Fosters Team Collaboration: Feedback among surgical teams promotes a culture of openness and mutual improvement.

The Dual Nature of Feedback

Feedback comes in many forms, each serving a unique purpose in the surgical field:

  • Patient Feedback: This includes comments on the patient’s experience, from the initial consultation through to post-operative care. It offers direct insights into the patient’s perspective, highlighting what went well and what could be better.
  • Peer Feedback: This involves constructive critiques from fellow surgeons and medical staff. It’s particularly valuable for its focus on technical aspects of surgery and patient management.

Incorporating feedback effectively into surgical practice requires a structured approach:

Seek Feedback Proactively: Don’t wait for feedback to come to you. Ask for it from both patients and peers.

Create a Safe Environment for Sharing: Encourage an atmosphere where feedback is viewed as a tool for improvement, not criticism.

Reflect and Act: Take time to reflect on the feedback received and implement changes where necessary.

Insights from a Surgical Leader

A prominent figure in the medical community has shown how embracing feedback can lead to remarkable achievements in surgery. Having performed nearly 1000 robotic surgeries, his approach to feedback has been instrumental in refining his techniques and improving patient outcomes. He underscores the importance of feedback in three key areas:

  • Technical Proficiency: Constant feedback on surgical techniques has allowed him to stay at the forefront of robotic surgery, making him one of the busiest robotic surgeons in his region.
  • Patient Satisfaction: By paying close attention to patient feedback, he has been able to make adjustments that significantly enhance the patient experience.
  • Professional Development: Feedback from peers has been a cornerstone of his growth, enabling him to take on leadership roles such as Chief of Staff and Director of the Credentials Committee.

Leveraging Feedback for Surgical Success

To maximize the benefits of feedback, surgeons should adapt several practices:

  • Establish Regular Feedback Mechanisms: This could be through patient surveys, peer review meetings, or informal discussions.
  • Embrace Technology: Use software and apps designed to collect and analyze feedback efficiently.
  • Engage in Continuous Learning: View feedback as an opportunity to learn and grow, rather than a critique of your abilities.

Feedback is more than just words; it’s a catalyst for transformation in the surgical field. By embracing it, surgeons can continually enhance their skills, improve patient care, and lead their teams more effectively. It’s a journey of ongoing improvement, where each piece of feedback is a step towards greater surgical success.


Feedback plays a pivotal role in the world of surgery, offering a pathway to excellence that benefits patients, surgeons, and the entire medical team. By embracing feedback with an open mind and a commitment to continuous improvement, surgeons can elevate their practice to new heights. It’s clear that in the quest for surgical success, feedback is an invaluable ally, guiding surgeons toward better outcomes, higher patient satisfaction, and professional growth.

Published by: Holy Minoza


This article features branded content from a third party. Opinions in this article do not reflect the opinions and beliefs of Miami Wire.